Was an Innocent Citizen Entrapped by the State?

Close Up Japan | 国家権力が無実の市民を陥れた⁉

Was an Innocent Citizen Entrapped by the State?

In 1966 four members of a family were murdered in Shizuoka Prefecture and pro boxer HAKAMADA Iwao was arrested. Hakamada had insisted on his innocence from the outset, but was sentenced to death. However, his support network has continued to protect him, and on March 27 this year, Shizuoka District Court suspended his death sentence and ordered his release. Freed after 48 years, Hakamada didn’t believe the news when he was notified and said, “It’s a lie.” During his long imprisonment, he lived in fear of being executed and it’s been reported that he displays signs of dementia and delusion. Said to have confessed, Hakamada endured the prosecution’s questioning for an average of 12 hours a day on consecutive days. The court did not accept 44 out of the 45 testimonies given as evidence as these had been obtained illegally. Furthermore, based on the opinion of a DNA expert, the court concluded that the five pieces of blood stained clothing, which had been considered to be key evidence, were not stained with Hakamada’s blood. This clothing should have been called into question from the beginning; it was suspicious that it had been found 14 months later, after the trial had already got underway. Now that the technology for DNA testing has improved, more than 140 death row inmates have been proven innocent in the USA. Making this judgment, the court severely reprimanded the prosecution: “It is reasonable to conclude that the evidence was fabricated after the fact.” With so many questions raised about guilty verdicts, people’s mistrust of the courts is deepening. It’s been pointed out that up until now, things were organized so that prosecutors and judges were in league with one another and this led to the creation of trumped up charges. A sentence is decided by the majority of judges involved, and one of the original judges issuing the death sentence, had insisted that Hakamada was innocent. However, his death sentence had been decided, and this judge has considered himself guilty of attempted murder. Now the crimes and humanity of those who fabricated evidence to turn innocent people into criminals in order to safeguard the power of the state, are called into question. (From May issue, 2014 / 2014年5月号より)

1966せんきゅひゃくろくじゅうろくねん
Sen kyuuhyaku rokujuu roku/1966 nen
nineteen sixty-six [year]
ni
in
静岡県しずおかけん
Shizuoka Ken
Shizuoka Prefecture
de
in
一家いっか4にん
ikka yo/4 nin ga
four members of (a) family
ころされ、
korosare,
were murdered and
プロぷろボクサーぼくさー
puro’bokusa- no
pro boxer
袴田はかまだいわおさんが
HAKAMADA Iwao san ga
Hakamada Iwao
逮捕たいほされました。
taiho saremashita.
was arrested.
袴田はかまださんは
Hakamada san wa/ha
Hakamada
最初さいしょ
saisho
(the) outset
から
kara
from
無実むじつ
mujitsu o/wo
(his) innocence
主張しゅちょうつづけました
shuchou shitsuzu/dukemashita
had insisted on
が、
ga,
but
死刑しけい
shikei ga
death
確定かくていしてしまいました。
kakutei shite shimaimashita.
was sentenced to
しかし
Shikashi
however
支援しえん団体だんたい
shien’dantai ga
(his) support network
擁護ようご
yougo
to protect (him)
つづけ、
shitsuzu/duke,
has continued and
今年ことし
kotoshi no
this year
3月さんがつ27にじゅうななにち
san/3 gatsu nijuu shichi/27 nichi,
(on) March twenty-seventh
静岡しずおか地方ちほう裁判所さいばんしょ
Shizuoka Chihou Saibansho wa/ha
Shizuoka District Court
再審さいしん決定けってい
saishin o/wo kettei shi
suspended (his) death sentence and
袴田はかまださんの
Hakamada san no
his <Hakamada’s>
釈放しゃくほう
shakuhou o/wo
release
めいじました。
meijimashita.
ordered
48よんじゅうはちねん
Yonjuu hachi/48 nen
forty eight years
ぶりに
buri ni
after
釈放しゃくほうされた
shakuhou sareta
freed
袴田はかまださんは、
Hakamada san wa/ha,
Hakamada
そのらせを
sono shirase o/wo
(the) news
けた
uketa
(he) was notified
とき
toki
when
しんじず、
shinjizu,
didn’t believe and
「うそだ」
“Uso da”
(it)’s (a) lie
to
[that]
いました。
iiimashita.
said
なが
Nagai
(his) long
拘置こうち生活せいかつ
kouchi’seikatsu
imprisonment [life]
あいだ
no aida,
during
死刑しけい執行しっこう
shikei’shikkou
being executed
no
of
恐怖きょうふにおびえながら
kyoufu ni obie nagara
in fear
き、
iki,
(he) lived and
袴田はかまださんに
Hakamada san ni
he <Hakamada>
認知症にんちしょう
ninchishou
dementia
ya
and
妄想もうそう
mousou
delusion
no
of
症状しょうじょう
shoujou ga
signs
みられる
mirareru
displays
to
that
報道ほうどうされています。
houdou sarete imasu.
(it)’s been reported
自供じきょう」したと
“Jikyou” shita to
to have confessed
される
sareru
said
袴田はかまださんは、
Hakamada san wa/ha,
Hakamada
連日れんじつ
renjitsu
(on) consecutive days
平均へいきん
heikin
(an) average
12じゅうに時間じかん
juu ni/12 jikan
(of) twelve hours (a day)
にもおよ
nimo oyobu
for
検察けんさつ
kensatsu no
(the) prosecution’s
調しらべを
torishirabe o/wo
questioning
けていました。
ukete imashita.
endured
裁判所さいばんしょ
Saibansho wa/ha
(the) court
違法いほう
ihouna
illegally
調しらべがあった
torishirabe ga atta
(these) had been obtained
として、
to shite,
as
証拠しょうこ
shouko
evidence
とされる
to sareru
(given) as
供述きょうじゅつ調書ちょうしょ
kyoujutsu’chousho
(the) testimonies
45よんじゅうごつう
yonjuu go/45 tsuu
forty-five
のうち
no uchi
out of
44よんじゅうよんつう
yonjuu yon/44 tsuu wa/ha
forty-four
採用さいようしませんでした。
saiyou shimasendeshita.
did not accept
さらに、
Sarani,
furthermore
DNAでぃーえぬえー鑑定かんてい
DNA kantei
(the) opinion of (a) DNA expert <DNA testing>
にもとづき
ni motozu/duki
based on
裁判所さいばんしょ
saibansho wa/ha
(the) court
重要じゅうよう
juuyouna
to be key
証拠しょうこ
shouko to
evidence
される
sareru
(which) had been considered
5てん
go/5 ten
(the) five pieces
no
of
染まっ
chi ni somatta
blood stained
衣類いるいは、
irui wa/ha,
clothing
袴田はかまださんの
Hakamada san no chi
Hakamada’s blood
ではない
dewa/ha nai
were not (stained with)
to
that
結論けつろんづけました。
ketsuron zu/dukemashita.
concluded
その衣類いるいについては
Sono irui ni tsuite wa/ha
this clothing
裁判さいばん
saiban ga
(the) trial
はじまって
hajimatte
had already got underway
から
kara
after <from>
1いちねん2ヵ月かげつ
ichi/1 nen ni/2 kagetsu
fourteen months
go ni
later
発見はっけんされたもの
hakken sareta mono
(it) had been found
de
that
うたがわしいと、
utagawashii to,
(it) was suspicious
当初とうしょ
tousho
(the) beginning
から
kara
from
疑問ぎもん
gimon ga
question
たれていました。
motarete imashita.
should have been called into
DNAでぃーえぬえー鑑定かんてい
DNA kantei
(for) DNA testing
技術ぎじゅつ
gijutsu ga
(the) technology
発達はったつした
hattatsu shita
has improved
いま
ima,
now (that)
アメリカあめりか
Amerika
the USA
では
dewa/ha
in
140ひゃくよんじゅうにん
hyaku yonjuu/140 nin
one hundred forty [people]
以上いじょう
ijou no
more than
死刑囚しけいしゅう
shikeishuu ga
death row inmates
のち
nochi ni
[later]
無実むじつ
mujitsu to
innocent
判明はんめいしました。
hanmei shimashita.
have been proven
今度こんど判決はんけつ
Kondo no hanketsu
this judgment
では、
dewa/ha,
making
裁判所さいばんしょ
saibansho wa/ha
(the) court
証拠しょうこ
“Shouko ga
(the) evidence
から
ato kara
after (the fact)
ねつぞうされた
netsuzousareta
was fabricated
to
that
るのが
miru no ga
to conclude
合理的ごうりてき
gouriteki”
(it) is reasonable
to
[that]
検察けんさつ
kensatsu o/wo
(the) prosecution
きびしく
kibishiku
severely
批判ひはんしました。
hihan shimashita.
reprimanded
おおくの
Ooku no
so many
疑問点ぎもんてん
gimonten ga
questions
ありながら
ari nagara
raised with
有罪ゆうざいとした
Yuuzai to shita
guilty verdicts
ことに
koto ni
about
裁判所さいばんしょ
saibansho
(the) courts
への
e/he no
of
国民こくみん
kokumin no
people’s
不信ふしん
fushin wa/ha
mistrust
ふかまっています。
fukamatte imasu.
is deepening
これまで
Kore made
up until now
検察けんさつ
kensatsu
prosecutors
to
and
裁判官さいばんかん
saibankan
judges
とが
to ga
so that
んで
kunde
were in league with one another and
事態じたいすすめられ、
jitai ga susumerare,
things were organized
それが
sore ga
this
冤罪えんざい
enzai o/wo
trumped up charges
んできた
unde kita
led to (the) creation (of)
to
that
指摘してきされてきました。
shiteki sarete kimashita.
(it)’s been pointed out
判決はんけつ
Hanketsu wa/ha
(a) sentence
裁判官さいばんかん
saibankan
(involved) judges
no
of
多数決たすうけつ
tasuuketsu
(the) majority
de
by
まります
kimarimasu
is decided
が、
ga,
and
死刑しけい判決文はんけつぶん
shikei’hanketsubun o/wo
(the) death sentence
いた
kaita
issuing
元裁判官もとさいばんかん
moto’saibankan
(the) original judges
no
of
一人ひとり
hitori wa/ha
one [person]
無罪むざい
muzai
(Hakamada) was innocent
o/wo
that
主張しゅちょうしました。
shuchou shimashita.
had insisted
しかし、
Shikashi,
however
死刑しけい判決はんけつ
shikei’hanketsu ga
(his) death sentence
まってしまい、
kimatte shimai,
had been decided and
この裁判官さいばんかん
kono saibankan wa/ha
this judge
みずからを
mizukara o/wo
himself
殺人さつじん未遂犯みすいはん
satsujin’misuihan to
guilty of attempted murder
つづけてきました。
semetsuzu/dukete kimashita.
has considered
国家こっか権力けんりょく
Kokka’kenryoku no
(the) power of (the) state
メンツめんつ
mentsu
safeguard
のために、
no tame ni,
in order to
証拠しょうこ
shouko o/wo
evidence
ねつぞうして
netsuzou shite
(who) fabricated
つみなき
tsuminaki
innocent
にん
hito o/wo
people
犯人はんにん
hannnin ni
criminals
仕立したげた
shitate ageta
to turn into
ひとたち
hitotachi
those
no
of
つみ
tsumi
(the) crimes
to
and
人間性にんげんせいが、
ningensei ga,
humanity
いま
ima
now
われます。
towaremasu.
are called into question

More from Hiragana Times

Learn anytime, anywhere and experience more on app

Explore Japanese culture with Hiragana Times

Subscribe
00:00 / 00:00